SICP Exercise 2.95 non-integer operations in gcd

Exercise 2.95.  Define P1, P2, and P3 to be the polynomials




Now define Q1 to be the product of P1 and P2 and Q2 to be the product of P1 and P3, and use greatest-common-divisor (exercise 2.94) to compute the GCD of Q1 and Q2. Note that the answer is not the same as P1. This example introduces noninteger operations into the computation, causing difficulties with the GCD algorithm.61 To understand what is happening, try tracing gcd-terms while computing the GCD or try performing the division by hand.

SOLUTION

 See here:

 SICP Exercise 2.95

You can see from the result that the gcd algorithm is not working properly. The result is just a number which is clearly wrong.

 The 'print-poly' procedure came in very handy here. I could print the various stages of polynomials in a readable format.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

SICP Exercise 4.18 a alternative strategy for interpreting internal definitions

Exercise 4.18.   Consider an alternative strategy for scanning out definitions that translates the example in the text to (lambda < vars >   (let ((u '*unassigned*)         (v '*unassigned*))     (let ((a < e1 >)           (b < e2 >))       (set! u a)       (set! v b))     < e3 >)) Here  a  and  b  are meant to represent new variable names, created by the interpreter, that do not appear in the user's program. Consider the  solve  procedure from section  3.5.4 : (define (solve f y0 dt)   (define y (integral (delay dy) y0 dt))   (define dy (stream-map f y))   y) Will this ...
Read more

SICP Exercise 3.11 make-account internal definitions with local state

Image
Exercise 3.11.    In section  3.2.3  we saw how the environment model described the behavior of procedures with local state. Now we have seen how internal definitions work. A typical message-passing procedure contains both of these aspects. Consider the bank account procedure of section  3.1.1 : (define (make-account balance)   (define (withdraw amount)     (if (>= balance amount)         (begin (set! balance (- balance amount))                balance)         "Insufficient funds"))   (define (deposit amount)     (set! balance (+ balance amount))     balance)   (define (dispatch m)     (cond...
Read more

SICP Exercise 3.13 make-cycle

Image
Exercise 3.13.    Consider the following  make-cycle  procedure, which uses the  last-pair  procedure defined in exercise  3.12 : (define (make-cycle x)   (set-cdr! (last-pair x) x)   x) Draw a box-and-pointer diagram that shows the structure  z  created by (define z (make-cycle (list 'a 'b 'c))) What happens if we try to compute  (last-pair z) ? SOLUTION The code is here: Exercise 3.13 make-cycle The box-and-pointer diagrams are here:
Read more